How reproducible is ecology?

Aud and Matt

Reproducibilty

The Turing Way Community. This illustration is created by Scriberia with The Turing Way community, used under a CC-BY 4.0 licence. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3332807

7 BES journals (2017 - 2024)

  • Does the paper use data/code? If so, are they archived?
  • Where were the data/code archived?
  • Can the archived data/code be located, downloaded and opened?
  • What file extensions do the archived data/code files use?
  • Do the archived data/code have a README (or equivalent)? If so, how useful is it?
  • How complete is the archived data?
  • How good is the code annotation?
  • Are the data/code citable?

Cooper, N., & (2026). Data- and code-archiving in the British Ecological Society journals: Present status and recommendations for future improvements. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 17, 1954–1966. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.70338

Is the data/code archived?

Located, downloaded and opened?

File extensions

Readme

Reviewed papers from 6 journals (2023–2026)

Figure 1: Number of papers reviewed in 2023: n = 44, 2024: n = 54, 2025: n = 59, 2026: n = 64

Data and code availability (2023–2026)

Figure 2: Data and code availability by year.

2023–2026: data and code availability by journal

Figure 3

Exercise (1/2)

Make 6 groups.

Choose one of the following journals and select a random issue from 2026:

  • Methods in Ecology and Evolution

  • Journal of Ecology

  • OIKOS

  • American Naturalist

  • Journal of Animal Ecology

  • Ecological Monographs

Exercise (2/2)

For each paper in this issue check:

  • Is the data available and can you download it? Repo or supplement file? In what format is the data available (xlsx, csv, txt, etc.)?

  • Is the code available? Choose one figure/analysis. Is the data and code for this figure/analysis available? Try to run the code, can you replicate the figure/analysis.

  • Add the data to this google spreadsheet and get a snack 🍪